Several of my photographer buddies recently got obsessed with the «class question.» Basically: are we working-class stiffs, small-business owners, or what? What does this heavy chunk of metal and glass in our hands—acting as both hammer and sickle—actually turn us into?
Two stories immediately came to mind. Both are about that extreme state of detachment this job pushes you into. The thin line between “capturing raw reality” and simply staying human. ↴
Story one. I was hired to shoot the public farewell ceremony for Olympic skiing champion Alexey Prokurorov in 2008. Practically the entire Russian skiing world showed up. At the entrance, one of his young students broke down sobbing, and there I was, photographing her from three feet away. A wild, wild state to be in. This wasn’t harmless street photography or a noisy rally. In moments like that, all humanity drains out of you. You become pure function, just another mechanical part bolted onto the shutter.
Story two. A friend and I were walking down the street when we spotted two homeless men fighting at a bus stop thirty feet away. One was trying to jump under an oncoming tram; the other was holding him back. On pure autopilot, I reached for my camera. My professional reflex to «document social reality» kicked right in. Meanwhile, my companion—a cultured Jewish musician who carried a shoe brush in his briefcase and buffed his shoes on almost every escalator—ran over, wrapped his arms around the filthy man, and started whispering kind words to him. Thanks to him, to Oleg, I realized my road had taken a wrong turn somewhere.
When we throw around terms like «means of production» and «capitalists,» we’re borrowing the language of economists. Yet behind every theory sits a much simpler problem: what happens to your soul when life itself gets turned into a product? Let’s walk through the main economic frameworks. Let your own gut tell you which one actually fits our reality.
📋 Inside This Essay: Key Questions & Economic Lenses
Alright, let’s get into it. If we’re going to talk about «means of production» and «capitalists,» we need to pick a vocabulary. Here is how the major economic schools look at what we do.
Classical and Neoclassical Economics
The Pitch. The market regulates itself and naturally finds balance. Self-interest and competition keep the engine running, while supply and demand set the prices. Old-school classical economists cared about long-term growth and labor value. Neoclassicals zoomed in on microeconomics and how individual buyers behave.
Who the Photographer Is: You are a rational economic agent and an independent service provider in an open market. You calculate your overhead, set your day rate, and compete for gigs through quality, turnaround speed, and niche specialization. Price yourself too high, and clients walk. Price yourself too low, and you go broke and leave the industry. In theory, you earn exactly what your skill is worth right now.
What the Camera Is: It’s a capital good—an investment you make by skipping immediate spending in hopes of future payouts. Supply and demand set the retail price of the gear, while its value to you comes down to marginal utility. Put simply: how much extra cash will that new lens or second body actually bring in? The camera doesn’t create value out of thin air; it simply speeds up your workflow and helps you turn a profit.
The Critique. The biggest blind spot of classical theory is its obsession with an idealized market that ignores the sheer muscle of corporate giants. It assumes an economy full of tiny shops passively reacting to what buyers want. Look around—that’s not how things work anymore:Where Classical & Neoclassical Theory Falls Short ↴
Marxism
The Pitch. The clash between people who own the means of production and people forced to sell their time can’t be fixed without dismantling the class system. Marxists argue a revolutionary break is unavoidable because the state ultimately works for its real sponsors: big capital. After all, handing cash to a politician is called bribery, while lobbying is the exact same thing made legal and tidy.
Who the Photographer Is: Under capitalism, a solo shooter is a «petty bourgeois»—or, to put it bluntly, a worker who exploits themselves. Working solo, you wear two hats at once. You’re the exploited worker selling your labor-service on the open market, and you’re the mini-capitalist owning the camera and pocketing the check. The second you hire assistants, stylists, or retouchers and pay them less than the value their work brings in, you cross the line into classic capitalism, skimming surplus value off wage labor.
May Day: a left-wing rally in Moscow ↴
What the Camera Is: A textbook means of production. It’s the physical tool you use to process «raw material» (reality) into a finished product—a photo with both use-value and market price. Your labor creates all the value. The camera simply transfers its own cost onto the final files bit by bit as its shutter count climbs and the gear depreciates.
Where Marxism Falls Short ↴
The Critique. Non-Marxist economists usually attack Marxism from a few familiar angles:
- Workers and bosses sign contracts freely, so there’s no coercion and the class war is exaggerated.
- Conflict is normal, and the government acts as a fair referee.
- You don’t need a revolution to build a welfare state. (Though let’s be honest: Western social democracies mostly bought that stability by importing cheap migrant labor and shipping dirty factories off to poorer countries. Zoom out, and it’s the exact same exploitation—just exported.)
- Splitting the world into «exploiters» and «exploited» gets messy when small business owners think they serve the customer. Today, an independent creator mostly ends up serving the shareholders of whatever platform hosts their work.
Most of the counterarguments here are already covered in the classical critique above. I’ll just add one thing: Marx never saw the demographic collapse coming, and that changes the math completely.
The Austrian School of Economics
The Pitch. Carl Menger wanted to prove that economics is a real science with universal laws, not just a pile of historical trivia. Those laws live inside individual human choices, not grand historical forces or class warfare. Menger essentially built praxeology—the logic of how people act and choose when resources are scarce and the future is foggy.
Who the Photographer Is: First and foremost, you’re an entrepreneur. Your real job isn’t pressing a button; it’s guessing what clients will want before they even know how to ask for it. You operate in the dark: betting on a visual style, carving out a niche, eating the financial risk, and juggling time, glass, and marketing. Your paycheck is your reward for reading the room right and taking the uncertainty off the client’s shoulders.
Photographs from the rally against Russia's accession to the WTO ↴
"Russian people came under the banners of various parties and movements. They were united by a desire to live in a great country worthy of its history. The main themes of the speeches were juvenile justice and accession to the WTO."
Among those taking part were oppositional politicians, conservative activists, and public figures.
Almost every TV channel brought its own crew. The remaining crowd could safely be divided into roughly equal parts, in descending order: journalists, bloggers, relatives and acquaintances, activists and counter-protesters, riot police (OMON), and local eccentrics. Total: around 500–700 people.
What the Camera Is: A «higher-order good.» Still, its value is 100% subjective and trickles down from whatever clients are willing to pay for the final shots. Without a photographer’s eye and a buyer’s interest, a flagship camera is just an expensive paperweight made of magnesium and glass.
Where the Austrian School Falls Short ↴
The Critique. Marxists obviously hate this approach. Today, though, Austrian economics works less as a grand philosophy and more as a toolkit—one that unexpectedly fits right into Big Data analytics. Nobody is running server farms on Menger’s 19th-century prose, of course; matrix math maps consumer choices in real time. Still, the core Austrian puzzle refuses to go away: how do you figure out what society actually needs without market price signals? That exact problem broke early Soviet central planning, though Big Data algorithms might soon try to fake those calculations without a free market.
Institutionalism
The Pitch. Institutionalists agree that friction between capital and labor drives economic history. Instead of asking «How do we end this fight?», they ask: «What laws, habits, and organizations keep this permanent tug-of-war from blowing up?» They tend to see the state as a neutral referee keeping the game playable.
Who the Photographer Is: You are a player operating inside a dense maze of rules. Your career depends just as much on those rules as on your talent:
- Formal institutions: Copyright law, 1099 freelance tax codes, LLC regulations, and permits.
- Informal institutions: Unwritten industry codes around pricing, client etiquette, visual trends, and word-of-mouth trust.
What the Camera Is: Not just hardware, but an asset backed by legal property rights. Your camera—and the RAW files coming out of it—only hold commercial value because copyright law exists. Strip away intellectual property enforcement, and anyone could grab your photos for free, dropping the market value of your work to zero.
Here’s the catch: a camera’s earning power is propped up by legal norms. Means of production aren’t just physical objects; they are bundles of property rights—the legal right to use and profit from those objects. Real-world conflict isn’t a neat war between labor and capital. It’s a messy brawl between lobbyists, corporations, unions, and regulators fighting to rewrite the rulebook.
Where Institutionalism Falls Short ↴
The Critique. Institutionalism is great at explaining how rules shift over time, but it has no endgame—aside from endlessly patching the current system. It rarely explains what could ever force the government to side with regular freelancers over well-funded corporate lobbyists. And the way institutions actually shift—pharma lobbying, ESG quotas, culture-war deals—shows there is no neutral referee.
Post-Industrial & Information Society Theory
The Pitch. Daniel Bell and his peers argued that wealthy nations were moving past factories into an information economy. The main ideas:
- Knowledge and data become the real drivers of innovation and power, beating out land and physical muscle.
- The economy shifts from making stuff to services, research, education, and lifestyle.
- Specialists and knowledge workers become the fastest-growing group—a new «intellectual class.»
- Dealing with people (service) replaces dealing with machines as the core of daily work.
Who the Photographer Is: A creative entrepreneur mixing technical know-how with client management. Hire a couple of assistants or editors, and you turn into a micro-capitalist of the creative economy.
What the Camera Is: An intellectual amplifier rather than a factory loom. Your actual capital is taste, visual literacy, and ideas. Value comes from symbolic meaning, not the hardware hanging off your shoulder.
The Critique. Look at what actually happened: information got locked behind paywalls, and digital platforms turned into tollbooths. Big Tech built data monopolies. Meanwhile, the average stock photographer got demoted to a digital cottage worker doing five jobs at once—burning up to half their week on unpaid grunt work like keywording and metadata tagging. Platforms dump all the overhead onto creators while gutting editorial teams. Agencies routinely pocket 70–85% of every sale while investing zero dollars into producing the shoot. Operating globally, they play living costs and labor laws in different countries against each other to push payouts down and pad their margins. Digital tools didn’t invent this trap, of course. They just poured gasoline on trends that were already burning: The Bottom Line: Tech didn’t invent bureaucracy; it just handed bureaucrats a superpower. Where a creative workflow used to live, a «digital twin» now sits—and feeding that digital twin slowly eats the craft alive. Manuel Castells dreamed of a flat, democratic «network society.» What we got instead are hyper-centralized platform middlemen that set the rules for every artist and buyer while taking a cut of every click.Where Post-Industrial Theory Falls Short ↴
Keynesianism
The Pitch. The Great Depression of the 1930s blew up the idea that markets fix themselves fast. John Maynard Keynes argued that governments have to actively juice aggregate demand—cutting taxes, lowering interest rates, loosening credit, and pumping cash into the system. This playbook ruled Western economics for decades after World War II.
Who the Photographer Is: Half consumer, half small business living and dying by aggregate demand.
When the economy is booming and cash is flowing, people and brands throw money at weddings, conferences, and ad campaigns—and your calendar stays booked.
When a downturn hits, photography is one of the first line items families and marketing departments slash. Doesn’t matter how good your portfolio is; if the money dries up, the phone stops ringing.
What the Camera Is: An income-producing asset whose usefulness rises and falls with the broader economy. A Keynesian doesn’t care what a camera is in a vacuum. They care about keeping enough money sloshing around the economy so clients can actually afford to hire you. It’s a capital investment with strictly cyclical returns.
Where Keynesianism Falls Short ↴
The Critique. The 21st century gave financial markets brand-new ways to game the system. Cheap money printed by central banks—supposedly meant to help Main Street—rushed straight into Wall Street assets instead, because capital always takes the fastest shortcut to multiplying itself. The fallout? A massive wealth gap between asset holders and working people, plus nasty inflation (especially after pandemic stimulus sprees).
Even worse, endless Keynesian life support keeps «zombie» businesses breathing, blocking healthy market renewal and hooking both companies and regular people on government handouts. Look at the U.S. food stamp program (SNAP): in 1994, around 28 million out of 250 million Americans relied on it; by 2023, that number hit 42 million out of 340 million. Keynesianism works great as an ER defibrillator during a heart attack—but as a daily diet, it turns the patient into a junkie.
Conclusions
Every economic school gives you a different pair of glasses to look at your career. Marxism points out the class contradictions; neoclassical theory sees a voluntary, balanced trade; the Austrians spot a risk-taking entrepreneur; institutionalists see someone navigating legal contracts; and post-industrial thinkers see a knowledge creator in a digital arena.
Picking a framework isn’t just armchair philosophy—it comes down to your values and your gut. Do you see the economy as a battlefield or a marketplace of cooperation? Do you think free markets reward talent fairly, or just rig the game for big players? Are digital platforms freeing artists, or locking us into a slicker version of serfdom? Let your own moral compass decide which worldview tells the truth and points toward a fairer deal. At the end of the day, the economic story you believe shapes not just how you see the industry, but how you operate inside it.
Cheers,
Kirill Toll, Photographer
(playing armchair economist for the day)
Facets of Greatness: Little-Known Facts About the Debaters
Adam Smith
To Smith, The Theory of Moral Sentiments mattered far more than The Wealth of Nations. He viewed conscience as the «supreme judge» of human conduct and kept revising that book until the day he died, considering it his true masterpiece. On top of that, he successfully lobbied the University of Glasgow to abolish mandatory prayers before his lectures.
Carl Menger
While teaching at the University of Vienna in 1867, Menger publicly argued that marriage was an obsolete institution and that free love was the future of civil society. True to his word, he never officially married—yet he used his connections with Emperor Franz Joseph (whose son he had once tutored) to get his out-of-wedlock son Karl legally recognized as his rightful heir.
Karl Marx
His family nicknamed him «The Moor» because of his dark complexion. Beyond the heavy economic theory, he was a devoted dad who loved playing «cavalry» with his daughters—hitching himself to a makeshift carriage of living-room chairs and earning the honorary title of «an excellent horse» whenever he won their living-room races.
Vladimir Lenin
He was a die-hard hiker and traveler, especially in England, which he knew inside out. Lenin spoke fluent English and even translated Sidney and Beatrice Webb’s massive two-volume history of British trade unionism into Russian during his Siberian exile. Later, working at the British Museum in London, he loved that every reader got their own individual desk to focus without distractions.
John Maynard Keynes
One of the most influential economists of the 20th century collected modern art—owning works by Picasso, Cézanne, and Modigliani—and raised prize pigs on his farm in Sussex. His wife, Russian ballerina Lydia Lopokova, even served as his unofficial interpreter during talks with the Soviet delegation at the Bretton Woods Conference.
Thorstein Veblen
Students and colleagues alike thought he was a total eccentric. His lectures were a deadpan stream of erudition mixing medieval Latin quotes with Chicago street slang, all delivered in a thick Norwegian accent. He also claimed to possess a «highly developed sense of economy»—his polite excuse for pathological laziness.
Daniel Bell
He famously described himself as a «socialist in economics, a liberal in politics, and a conservative in culture.» Before becoming a professor at Harvard and Columbia, he spent nearly twenty years working as a journalist sympathetic to the left, giving him an insider’s view of how modern society actually ticks.
Immanuel Wallerstein
Before pioneering world-systems analysis, he spent years studying postcolonial Africa, watching firsthand how political independence failed to end economic dependence on former colonial powers. He spent nearly four decades writing his four-volume The Modern World-System, arguing that the poverty of the «periphery» and the wealth of the «core» are two sides of the exact same coin.































































































Look at that camera: a classic means of production. The photographer is a worker, and the body in his hands is an instrument of alienated value. The second he hires a retoucher, he turns into a capitalist stealing surplus value!
come off it, Karl! A photographer is a free market participant guided by the «invisible hand.» He and his retoucher trade labor voluntarily to their mutual benefit. The market is a self-regulating harmony!
Harmony? Smith, you’re describing an 18th-century butcher shop! Today’s market is a dictatorship of corporate giants. Your «small firms» merely react to demand manufactured by tech monopolies. A photographer isn’t «free»—he’s trapped inside the price tag of his gear, forced to shoot endlessly just to pay it off before it goes obsolete. That’s not free exchange; that’s market coercion!
And don’t forget the state! It’s no «night watchman,» Smith. It’s the biggest buyer in town and the chief lobbyist for the corporations making those cameras. Your precious «harmony» is bankrolled by tax breaks and subsidies for giants!
Karl, the value of a camera is entirely subjective. Without a photographer’s entrepreneurial eye, that flagship body is just dead weight. A photographer’s income is a well-earned premium for taking risks and anticipating demand in the dark!
Foresight? When a studio owner works an assistant for twelve hours and pays him for four, calling the rest a «risk premium»—that’s plain robbery. «Risk» doesn’t press the shutter button!
Wrong! It’s that exact risk that convinced him to invest in the gear instead of blowing his savings. Without his risk, that assistant wouldn’t even have a job. Your expropriation kills any incentive to innovate. Who decides what gets photographed if there are no market price signals? Central planners? They’ll flood the country with photos of cows when people actually want sunsets!
You’re all arguing about ghosts! A camera is an asset whose value is defined by legal institutions. Strip away copyright law, and your photographer is broke. The real fight isn’t about «labor»—it’s about who controls the rulebook!
Veblen, your «rules» are just the will of the ruling class written into law! You call bribery «lobbying» and celebrate «transparency.» Institutions merely put a polite mask over capital’s grip on labor.
Not quite, Vladimir Ilyich. Institutions evolve. Unions, licensing laws, and freelance tax codes are institutions too. We aren’t looking for a violent revolution; we’re building rules that keep a permanent conflict manageable. The state is the referee!
A referee who always blows the whistle in favor of the stadium owner! Digitalization just made that «refereeing» total: now every move a photographer makes is tracked, scored, and throttled by an algorithm. Those aren’t rules—that’s a digital prison camp!
But platforms give access to knowledge! Anyone with a camera is now part of the global network. That’s democratization!
That’s the democratization of poverty. Platforms dump all the costs (attribution, taxes, risks) onto the creator. The stock photographer is a digital slave who pays for his own chains, buying a new camera every year just to meet the platform’s «standards.» Your «service» in New York only works because the cobalt for that camera’s battery is mined by children in Congo. Platforms are the new metropoles. They play the global inequality game, pitting the cottage photographer from the periphery against the professional from the core to drive the price down and pocket 85% of the rent!
All this is empty talk without aggregate demand. In a crisis, the photographer starves first. The state must print money, hand out SNAP coupons and cheap credit so people can at least order a passport photo!
Your «cheap money» is poison! You’re propping up «zombie photographers» nobody needs. You infantilize business and kill «creative destruction.» Your help leads to inflation that will eat the photographer’s camera faster than he can pay it off!
In the long run we are all dead, Menger! If we don’t support demand now, your «free Atlas» will pawn his camera for pennies, and there’ll be no «destruction»—just a graveyard!
Listen to them! They’re dividing your crumbs. Digital audits replaced trust. Once they trusted the photographer; now they demand a «digital footprint» for the report. You are slaves of the interface! You’re alienated even from the meaning of your own creativity.
Only if you expropriate that data! While the algorithm belongs to the shareholder, the photographer is just a «sensor» for profit extraction. Digitalization is a catalyst of the old exploitation. The choice is simple: either you serve the «digital twin» of your labor for the platform owners’ profit, or you take power over the code into your own hands!
Conscience is your last economic school. That «camera brick» of yours is either a tool of liberation or a gadget in a gilded cage. ¡Victoria o muerte!
Unbelievable. Just unbelievable. Marx, Smith, Keynes, Lenin, Guevara — all great guys, very smart, everybody’s saying it. And they all met in a Russian blog. A Russian blog! Nobody knew this was possible. Tremendous. This is going to be a great deal, believe me. The best deal. We’re going to bring them all in, and they’re going to work. Huge.
特朗普同志,您觉得奇怪,我倒不觉得。俄罗斯的博客,恰恰是理论和零下十度相遇的地方。聪明人聚在一起,讨论谁剥削谁,而摄影师却站在雪地里。好的交易,是让每个人都暖和。先从帽子开始吧。
Либеральная экономика себя дискредитировала.